The setting in “A Rose for Emily” is used to reflect the values of the Old South versus the values of the industrialized, growing New South. This conflict occurs between Homer Barron and Miss Emily.
As in “A Rose for Emily,” “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” uses setting to expound upon the theme. Because she was unable to let go of her father’s death, Emily falls in love with Homer Barron. p This occurs between the townspeople and Miss Emily.
She ultimately becomes the representation of the town’s past and a monument among the “august names” in the Confederate graveyard (Faulkner 243). Although he was only trying to protect her, this raises a question: did Emily’s father love her a bit much?
This could have been the reasoning behind poisoning Homer Barron—Emily sought a man much like her father, but was terrified of losing him.
Upon the death of her father, Emily becomes confused and disoriented.
She believes that her father is not dead, and to the townspeople’s dismay, refuses to permit anyone to bury him.But the most important involves her first jilting by her fiancé George, and her second, by Jesus. The Board of Aldermen tried to readmit her taxes, but Emily refused to pay them. Alive, Emily’s father was overprotective, overbearing, and stubborn.There are three major conflicts in“A Rose for Emily:” man vs. When the mailboxes went up around the town, Emily refused to hang hers. He refused to let any man near Emily—there was a picture painted of the two; “We had long thought of them as a tableau, Miss Emily a slender figure in white in the background, her father a spraddled silhouette in the foreground, his back to her and clutching a horsewhip…” (Faulkner 246).This “smell” also foreshadows the ending, reminding the townspeople of a tomb.The house contains a level of dust that is overbearing—it is even depicted as “patient and binding” (Faulkner 250).The story begins in Granny’s bedroom, where she is sick, but ultimately takes place inside her stream of consciousness. Homer is attracted to the male company of the town instead of her, so in order to keep him, Emily poisons him. Because she is so old-fashioned and proper, the townspeople despise her.She begins to describe her past; the children she raised, the lamps she lit, her first husband, etc. They continue to “pity her” throughout the story, gossiping about the way she conducts herself and the things that have happened in her life.Although she continued on with her life—remarried, had four children, and lived to be an old woman—the loss of George continued to affect her.Then, as she took her last breath, the “bridegroom” (Jesus) betrayed her as well.The third and final conflict involves man versus supernatural.There was “again no bridegroom and the priest in the house” (Porter 769).