False Confession Essays

That is, I think one might reasonably object that they are overly focused on the possibility of false confessions without saying much about the utility of true confessions.However, their specific proposal that interrogations be video-taped does not seem to diminish the ability of police to effectively interrogate suspects and, when possible, to elicit a confession.

Tags: Utoronto Engineering Science ThesisDirection EssayEssay On Proverb Charity Begins At HomeSolving Quadratic Equations By Factoring Practice ProblemsBest Travel Essays ItalyMedical Student Essay Competitions 2014Long Day'S Journey Into Night Essay QuestionsHl Mencken EssaysParts Of Essay Writing

Imagine, for example, the following two systems: (1) Almost no innocent persons are ever convicted, but a very high percentage of recidivist offenders are able to escape conviction, (2) A very high percentage of offenders are caught and brought to justice; however, a small but non-negligible percentage (say 3%) of innocent persons are unjustly caught in the system and thus wrongly punished for crimes they never committed.Trial jurors, we are told, are inclined to give disproportionate weight to a confessions, even taking it to outweigh so-called hard evidence.As a characteristic example, Kassin and Gudjonsson cite the case of Bruce Godschalk.Indeed, they conclude their essay by citing a study showing that police largely found the practice of video-taping to be quite useful and not to inhibit criminal investigations.So, even if one thinks that Kassin and Gudjonsson are a bit one-side in focusing on false confessions, ultimately I think these authors provide a compelling argument for the need for such reforms as mandatory video-taping of police interrogations. True Crimes, False Confessions, Scientific American Mind, July, pp. My basic point is that social justice requires not only that we protect innocent individuals from prosecution, but that we hold guilty persons accountable for their actions.While I think that this is a reasonable worry to raise given the tenor of Kassin and Gudjonssons article, I do not think it ultimately undermines their argument.Even when DNA evidence proved Godschalk could not have been the rapist, the District Attorney of the case refused to release him from prison, stating that I trust my detective and his tape-recorded evidence (Kassin and Gudjonsson, 2005, p. Because of this tendency on the part of jurors and prosecutors, together with the facts listed above regarding the potential for unrestricted interrogations to elicit false confessions, Kassin and Gudjonsson argue for the need to reform police interrogation tactics.Underlying their argument is the implicit moral principle that social justice requires that we do everything we can to minimize the potential to wrongly convict innocent persons.But long before the cases of Adnan Syed, Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey were brought to the public’s attention, we and other researchers have been hard at work studying how it is that innocent people sometimes go to prison for crimes they did not commit.In fact, a recent report documented that in 2015, there were a record number of exonerations in the United States.

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments False Confession Essays

The Latest from ecotext2.ru ©