Tags: American History X Movie EssaysConsumer Economics College CourseworkHow To Write A Self Assessment PaperVideo Business PlanPolitics And The Constitution Essays On British GovernmentSports Writing SHow To Write A Dissertation ConclusionPsychological Egoism And Ethical Egoism EssayCompare Contrast Wwi Wwii EssayBusiness Plan To Open A Gym
Next week, a judge will decide whether he should be imprisoned (the crime carries a potential sentence of between four and eight years).It’s not an edifying tale, in that no one comes out of it particularly well: not the author (trying to argue that the sharing of his five-year-old thesis constituted harm), not publishers (whose policies around theses publication discourage electronic sharing of theses and underpin the idea of harm), not the prosecution (blindly applying a law really intended to protect commercial content against commercial piracy), and perhaps not even the researcher (arguing that he thought something being online meant it was public domain).
Much of the coverage of the case has focused on whether copyright laws that enable such a sorry scenario can be fit for purpose, and whether open access solves the problem (I’m not sure it’s that simple, in that the issue here is not access, but copyright — Todd’s post earlier this week was timely, in this context).
For me, the thread that hasn’t been pulled much is whether online availability of a thesis precludes publication; I’ll come back to that after a quick recap.
(It should be noted that Scribd didn’t adopt its current business model, whereby authors can post their own work on the system and receive payments based on the views, until 2013 — i.e.
there was no commercial gain for Diego in posting the thesis to Scribd).
Which publishers still have policies that mean they won’t consider papers / books developed from theses that have previously been made available online?
Is this still a valid concern on behalf of the author in this case — has he really been harmed to the extent that another academic should be imprisoned? Ramirez et al., found “more than half of the science journals responding (51.4%) reported that manuscripts derived from openly accessible ETDs [Electronic Theses and Dissertations] are welcome for submission and an additional 29.1 percent would accept revised ETDs under certain conditions”. Dixon, "Application of neural networks to solve the routing problem in communication networks," Ph. dissertation, Murdoch Univ., Murdoch, WA, Australia, 1999. He’s a Colombian researcher currently on trial for sharing someone else’s thesis on the Scribd platform.In 2011, Diego Gómez found a 2006 thesis in a library.From what I can gather, it was online, but unpublished (perhaps on an intranet?quotes Carolina Botero (whose digital rights organization, Fundación Karisma, is helping Gómez) as saying this was rejected by the author as too low.The situation has been publicized by a wide range of other organizations including the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), Creative Commons, Internet Archive, Knowledge Ecology International, Open Access Button, Derechos Digitales, Open Coalition, Open Knowledge, The Right to Research Coalition, Open Media, Fight for the Future, USENIX, Public Knowledge, Web we Want, and Open Con (most of this list pulled from a letter of thanks from Gómez to his supporters, published on the Fundación Karisma website). Retrieved from Proquest Dissertations and Theses database. Academic coaches and leadership (Master’s thesis, Royal Roads University, Victoria, Canada).The page number is only given if a specific quotation or section of a source is referenced.This is the sentence that I am citing (Smith, 2016).